Recently a dispute over a personal guaranty on a loan went before the Third District Court of Appeal. That the case made it all the way to the appeals court was not surprising, as there were tens of millions of dollars on the line. As with so many commercial litigation matters, the outcome came down to the details of the drafting of the agreement. Given how much every detail can matter in these transactions, one thing to learn from this case is that it is extremely important to be sure you have skilled South Florida commercial litigation counsel on your side.
The transaction that set off the subsequent chain of events, including litigation, was a 2005 agreement for financing. Several entities, of which M.R. was a principal, reached an agreement with a bank for a revolving mortgage note and construction loan. The principal amount was $41 million. The entities intended to develop waterfront condominium homes in the Tampa area. M.R. personally guaranteed the loan.
Unfortunately for M.R. and his entities, the recession and the real estate market crash intervened. Most of the condo purchasers defaulted. By May 2008, the bank declared the loan in default due to non-payment. The bank moved to foreclose, and a $38.9 million judgment of foreclosure was entered. The obligation changed hands a few times and eventually a Tampa-area LLC emerged as the assignee.